Dew's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Mr Fix-It]

Hm, could use some work.

Well although the submission itself wasn't bad, it could use some definate work. For one, the graphics in it are pretty bad, things like shading straight lines and more than one color are non-existent in this flash, and that would have helped a lot in this submission. The story itself wasn't that great ether, it didin't capture my attention and it was just plain imature, in my eyes. Overall this submission isn't that great and I didin't like, hell I don't know who would. What did you get on this anyway?

[First C&B stick animation]

I suppose if you...

I suppose if you made this a long time ago then it dosen't really matter what I think of it, but my opinon is that I don't really like it. The story fails to grab my attention, at least not very much and it bareley makes any sense what so ever. Would have been nice if you made the characters a bit thicker, especially the stickman, just to make the graphics look better. Maybe some background info before making this would have also been nice. Overall I would have to say that this submission is average, especially for 05. Just put some more work into it and it should be far better.

[medevial retards 2]

Well, it's bad.

Simply put, this submission is bad. Maybe it's cause I don't understand what's happening, or maybe it's because of the abosluteley horrible graphics, but whichever it is, this submission is bad. It went so painstakingly slow that I lost attention in it, I don't know who would watch the whole thing anyway, but I just don't like this submission. Overall you can judge a flash by it's review's length and what does that tell you? Subtitles please? Poor flash.

[medevial retards]

Woah...

Well I got to tell ya this, it's pretty bad. The graphics are lame to say the least, and it simply just looks rushed. I found it hard to just follow the story let alone enjoy it. I mean a guy fights a dragon and then a random hall where they talk, I don't get it. Next time put more effort into your flash, maybe subtitles, or somthing of good quality. Overall, this is just simply, a bad flash animation.

[SaltyJello's Last Stand]

Interesting enough, I geuss...

Well, to be honest, I don't know what to say. This in my opinon, is just another one of those "Huge collabs, crew" submissions and I personally don't care for them, but this wasn't all bad. If you could count the "Socom" thing an actual graphics, then they were made quite well. I actually enjoyed the words that went through the story too, and it kept me watching throughout it because of that. All in all, I would say this is an okay submission. But nothing special about it, but I suppose you already know that.

[Story Time With Mohammed3]

What the hell?

What an odd ending to an otherwise pretty good submission. To start off, the animation and graphics in general, in this submission were very good. Each thing was dipicted very well an realisticley. The only down fall to it was the shortness of it. As I am reading the subtitles, which are absoluteley awesome to have, all of a sudden the guy stabs him and then some kid gets the middle finger. The first thing I said was "What the hell?" And then it ended, which is kind of an odd ending. I give you points for the lasting impression, but take away points for the sheer weirdness. Overall I would have to say this submission has a good score the way it is. A 3.3 is right where this submission should be.

JunkYardAnimations responds:

lol good enuff for me:), i started making more story times with mohammed, there's 5 in total now so plz check em out and review them too

[song 2 - blur music video]

Meh.

Well I didin't really enjoy this submission, it isn't bad by any means, but it isn't great ether. I was looking forward to the submission when it started, and when the line thing went, but it quickly ended, if you had continued that I might have really enjoyed this submission. Sure it's hard to do, but well worth the end result. From what I did see, the various backgrounds and things I saw was random, and creative a plus on any flash in my opinon. Overall though, it just failed to keep my attention and it didin't leave any lasting impression on me. Just another one of those "Meh" Submissions.

[RuneScape Deadly Noobs]

Hm..

Well I don't really get the full extent of the submission, because I only ever played Runscape for a month or so, maybe less, but I played enough to understand this flash. Although I didin't find the overall humor to be very funny, it did keep me watching, which is a rare thing from flashes, let alone Runescape ones. I can't really review on the graphics, but I can comment that they were pretty realistic to my understanding. All in all, a good submission, but nothing spectacular.

G79 responds:

thanks for a respectful view

[destroyed butnot defeated]

Not really interesting.

If you were looking at this submission, you would notice that it really dosen't manage to capture my attention very well. I mean sure, it's a claymation and you can't expect amasing quality, but in general this submission, I thought wasn't very good. The movements were slow, and dull and the story itself didin't attract me in anyway at all. Next time, try speeding things up, or doing somthing different entirely. Meh, that's just my personal opinon.

ATOMICCLOUD responds:

Here's the thing.
This is a masterpiece compared to other rip-offs that some people call claymations, and most people think a REAL animation like this one isn't good because it doesn't have blue blobs that are hardly creative, an over-used joke and some random reason for violence.
Claymation is way better than flash, it's original, creative and fun.
So that's my point. Oh, and the real king of clay is Ray Harryhausen, a great man who used to do animations for old monster films.
There, OK?