00:00
00:00
Dew

93 Art Reviews

38 w/ Responses

1 reviews is hidden due to your filters.

heh neat

I wouldn't call this submission all that great in my eyes, but yea it does depict that scene very nicely. It would've been nice to see had you maybe not made it so dark, I found it hard to really notice anything of value in this submission because it really was so dark. The little tidbits of color are a nice touch, and really provide the only point of depth to this submission. I like how the tri force is highlighted nicely, but again thats really the only thing that stands out for me in this submission. Overall, I think this submission is solid, nothing too bad, but nothing overly good either.

abhirao2001 responds:

Hi, thanks for your feedback.

An odd 3d image.

It's most definatly an odd 3d image. Sort of like those stair cases you see in people's minds sometimes in different t.v shows. The thing I don't like about this submission is that it's too dark. I also don't like how the shading doesn't add anything to the submission, it seems like you added too much shading to the submission and in some parts it gets too dark for its own good. And let's be honest here all it appears to be is a square like shape with stairs on them, nothing really that great about that. Maybe you got caught having the computer do too much work on this submission.

BenTibbetts responds:

Thanks for the comment.

Hm...

I'm not really sure what this submission actually is. Maybe you went off on something and then you quit halfway through, or maybe you rushed through it, but I found this submission to be way too dark for its own taste. It appears to be some sort of monster, but the the darkness takes away too much for you to really see. The red machine like light also doesn't really do anything for you, as it doesn't really clarify what the thing actually is. From my perspective it simply looks like a bunch of long mechanical rods or limbs that are floating out of clouds, not really something that spectacular.

BenTibbetts responds:

Again, thanks for the comment.

Ha

I always like pokemon submissions, particularly ones that make fun of pokemon, and this submission does that very well. The way you made the nose so big, but still in the same shade as the other parts of the submission was a very nice, and funny touch. Considering you didn't do the background I shouldn't really mention anything on it, but that's what brought this submission together. If the weedle itself is the legs of this submission the background is really the ankle and foot of the submission. It blends in well with the weedle and makes it easier to look at, and funnier in the long run. Good work on this submission.

TastesLikeBRAAAIINNS responds:

Thank you very much, I'm glad you took the time to evaluate this piece so thoroughly!

Meh

To me this submission isn't anything special. Essentially it's what appears to be a quick draw of a huminoid monkey, and to me that really isn't that special. The idea of this being on a t-shirt isn't bad at all, but as a stand alone submission it really isn't that great. I liked the light and dark in the corners I found that to really give this submission something extra to it. I also liked the design of the radio he was holding as it added a different style of line to the submission. The shading of the character was done well and I liked how you used the different shades of green, you might have had a bit too much of the same green in certain areas though and that is what makes me dislike it it some parts. All in all you have a good submission here, just not a great one.

Neat

I wouldn't say that this submission really has any great qualities to it, but I can say that it is a solid submission. The first thing I notice is the odd way the head doesn't really fit in with the rest of the person's body. Clearly the gun is supposed to be the main focus here, but I just can't get past the odd shaped head. I found the background to fit in well with what the person was wearing and you get a sort of feeling that it could be some sort of desert shooter or something. I like the dash of red in the corners as well, it adds a bit of flavour to an otherwise odd submission.

Average.

I guess you have your average Justin Bieber look going on here. It looks like a quick sketch maybe done in 15 or 20 minutes as well and that's why I don't really like this submission all that much. There's no color to it, so there isn't any actual emphasis anywhere. The one eye that you can see looks like he's actually wearing some sort of eyeliner or something, which takes away from the otherwise general appearance of the person. Not much to say on this one, as it really is just a quick sketch.

Riki responds:

It is indeed a quick sketch. i had lips i started on and never finished adn just built around it randomly. this is actually a girl.
I don't like coloring my pictures, and usually do everything in pencil... to each their own... i appreciate the criticism...

also... this was drawn before Bieber... i'd appreciate you don't ''generalize'' my photo with some poppy wannabe. :P

Meh

Maybe it's me but this looks like it's photoshopped to death. The various colors don't do anything for the submission, other than crowed it up. The color of her tail and the sky match up, but since the tail takes up such a large portion of the submission, it really takes away from the colors in the sky. I also found the rocks to be a tad bit odd shaped, and if anything rushed. You don't get a sense that she's in the water for one thing, and all in all it's not that great of a submission. Maybe it's just me, but I'm not impressed with this one.

CaffeiNix responds:

Yeah. I wanted to paint up a backgroud to establish that she is, in fact, sitting on rocks above water but I was feelin' lazy. The colors don't balance out well and I really should have just left it unfinished.

Not too bad.

The first thing I actually notice about this submission, after reading your script is the odd manner she's holding the bat almost robotic like. I find it hard to believe someone would hold a bat, even in a situation like that, quite like the way she's holding it. I do like the hair, as you mentioned as well in your script, I think that's the best part of this submission because it brings a sense of color to an otherwise dreary and dark scene. It's a neat little picture that certainly has some odd parts to it, but all in all it's a funny little thing to look at.

XxThumbsuckerxX responds:

Thank you, see the whole point of my comic is comedy. Most people shoot for horror & just the shock factor of everything. But I like my characters to not care as much, and focus more on stupid puns & gags. Plus this pink haired character, Rowan is a bit of a ditz. Not saying she's a complete idiot, but I like her to have a sense of cluelessness & lack of realization that she could be in danger. I agree with the bat, I wanted to fit it in & spent well more than an hour trying to do so. I pictured her trying to swing & then the zombie grabbing it, thus causing this back & forth tug of war kind of thing. I think it worked out nicely, but adding motion is very hard for me. I'm used to one person portraits mostly, so this was a BIG leap for me. Drawing two people in one picture, then having them interact. I think it's a good first try though. Thank you very much for your review! It was very helpful & I agree with all of it. So thanks, I really appreciate it. (:

A lot of hard work no doubt.

I can tell you put a lot of hard work into this submission, I can see it by the various designs you put into this submission, and how evenly spaced out the quality is. No single part is defined, but all parts of the submission are great quality. Obviously the lack of background takes away from the submission, but the overall death and ferocity of a machine like that is still here. I didn't really like the way you made the black powerlines of the character, I thought they were poor quality and seemed to fill in more space than actually do what they were supposed to; which is of course had some deapth to the submission. Other than that I liked this submission very much, good work.

Age 30

what

Joined on 2/4/05

Level:
43
Exp Points:
20,410 / 20,530
Exp Rank:
890
Vote Power:
8.44 votes
Rank:
Sup. Commander
Global Rank:
291
Blams:
9,287
Saves:
21,450
B/P Bonus:
60%
Whistle:
Bronze
Medals:
97